What Questions Are Asked on a Police Polygraph? Understanding the Process
Polygraph tests, also known as lie detector tests, are a controversial but sometimes used tool in police investigations. While the reliability of polygraphs is debated, understanding the types of questions asked is crucial to understanding the process. This isn't a simple "yes" or "no" affair; the questions are carefully crafted and strategically sequenced. This article explores the common question types and the overall structure of a typical polygraph examination.
What types of questions are asked during a polygraph?
Polygraph examinations typically involve three types of questions: irrelevant, relevant, and control questions.
-
Irrelevant Questions: These are designed to establish a baseline for the subject's physiological responses. They are unrelated to the crime under investigation and are typically simple and innocuous, such as "Is your name John Smith?" or "Is today Tuesday?" The examiner observes the subject's physiological responses—heart rate, breathing, skin conductivity—to these questions to establish a "normal" pattern.
-
Relevant Questions: These are the core questions focusing on the crime itself. Examples include direct questions about the subject's involvement, such as "Did you kill Mr. Jones?" or "Were you present at the scene of the robbery?" These are designed to elicit a deceptive response if the subject is guilty.
-
Control Questions: These are designed to be slightly deceptive, even for an innocent person. They address behavior similar to the crime but are not directly related to the case. For example, "Have you ever stolen anything in your life?" (even a small thing) is a common control question. The examiner compares responses to these questions with responses to relevant questions to detect deception. The underlying logic is that a guilty person would show more physiological stress to the relevant questions compared to the control questions, while an innocent person might show greater stress to the control questions due to their inherent deceptiveness.
What are some example questions?
The specific questions will vary significantly depending on the case. However, here are some examples to illustrate the different question types:
Case: Theft of a valuable necklace
- Irrelevant: "Is your name Jane Doe?" "Are you sitting in a chair?"
- Relevant: "Did you take Mrs. Smith's necklace?" "Were you in Mrs. Smith's house on the night of the theft?" "Do you know where the necklace is?"
- Control: "Have you ever taken something that didn't belong to you?" "Have you ever lied to avoid getting into trouble?"
How are the questions asked?
The order of questions is crucial. The examiner usually mixes irrelevant, relevant, and control questions to avoid predictability and to better gauge the subject's reactions. They may repeat questions to confirm patterns. The entire process can be quite lengthy and involve multiple question sets.
What if I'm innocent and fail a polygraph?
A significant criticism of polygraph testing is that it's not a perfectly accurate science. Innocent individuals can fail due to nervousness, anxiety, or misunderstanding of the questions. Furthermore, the interpretation of the physiological data is subjective, introducing further potential for error. A "failed" polygraph test, therefore, should not be considered definitive proof of guilt.
Are polygraph results admissible in court?
The admissibility of polygraph results in court varies greatly depending on the jurisdiction and specific circumstances. In many places, they are inadmissible as evidence because of concerns about their reliability and the potential for misuse.
Is a polygraph test always accurate?
No, polygraph tests are not always accurate. Their reliability is a subject of ongoing debate within the scientific and legal communities. Many factors can influence the results, including the subject's emotional state, medical conditions, and the expertise of the examiner.
In conclusion, while polygraph testing remains a part of some police investigations, the process is complex and the results should be interpreted cautiously. The questions are carefully structured to detect deception, but they don't provide definitive proof of guilt or innocence. Understanding the different question types and the limitations of the test is crucial for anyone facing a polygraph examination.
